Three

Audience Reviews

View More

Aug 18, 2018 Johnnie To delivers again with a taut suspense movie set in a hospital. You have an exhausted neurosurgeon at the end of her shift, a wounded robber from a violent robbery, the police officers who want information out of him, preferably before the bullet is removed from his head, and the impending threat of his accomplices who may or may not be attacking the police or rescuing their buddy. Skillfully ratcheting up the tension in classic Hitchcockian manner, the film erupts at the end leaving you cringing and wondering how all the pieces will land. Masterful film. See more Oct 20, 2017 If you love incompetent and asinine behavior chracters who get way to much screen time then you'll like this movie. Poor storyline that is hard to comprehend with parts that don't even matter to the whole story, they literally could have cut them out and it wouldnt have changed the story one bit (it's 90 minutes long but could've been shortened to 40 minutes without losing any value). I've always loved watching chinese and hong kong films but this one was utterly disappointing. I don't know who this director is, but many people give him high praise, but this film definitely does not warrant that. The whole movie was a jumbled mess with an unsatisfying and ridiculous ending. See more Sep 29, 2017 Unlikable characters....random acts of stupidity and little tension...the plot makes zero sense..there is one short "battle" that is film sort of cool...but mostly this is not good film See more jesse o @RT12547577 Jul 6, 2017 I've seen a few Johnnie To films in my lifetime. Perhaps not as many as I would like, but I've seen my fair share of them. This is news to people who may come across these reviews on Letterboxd, where I have 2899 reviews less than I do on Flixster (19 on Letterboxd to 2918 on Flixster, to be exact and I'm including this film in those numbers), but I find Johnnie To to be one of the best I've ever seen at crafting exquisite shootout sequences. There's a gracefulness to these scenes and how he crafts them that, really, very few people on this earth can actually match. Out of all the movies of his I've watched, Drug War has got to be my favorite. It's got a really compelling story and some excellent shootouts. Exiled also comes to mind immediately. This film, however, takes a more subdued approach to this as the film tells the story of this master criminal, after being shot in the head (and living) and refusing treatment at the hospital to remove the bullet that is in his brain, holding out for long enough to give his cronies, or something, enough time to get to the hospital to bust him out. This idea is flawed in theory since the longer the bullet is stuck in his head, the doctor wants to operate on him immediately, the more likely he is to be incapacitated permanently. I'll be honest, and this is referring to my Flixster reviews since this is my first Johnnie To review on Letterboxd, I don't think I've disliked a Johnnie To movie ever. From what I can see of my own reviews, no Johnnie To movie has ever received anything less than 3 stars. Well, that is, until today. Yea, I wasn't a big fan of this movie I'm being perfectly straightforward. I honestly think it's near impossible for this man to make a movie that is bad, considering his experience and track record. I think he's got enough experience to know how to, at least, craft a decent enough movie. And this is what this flick ends up being. I really did love this film's concept, because the big moment, that led to this criminal being sent to this hospital, happened off-screen. You don't actually get to see any of it so, in reality, there's no real reliable narrators here, as it were. You can't buy the cops' story that this criminal was shot in self-defense and you can't really trust the criminal with his manipulations and machinations to get his way. But, if I'm being fair, I just didn't find this film to be that interesting. I get the whole deal is to build up tension for when the criminal's buddies show up and the eventual shootout with the cops take place, but I just didn't find this form of storytelling to be that compelling. The film is certainly loquacious, but these people don't really seem to be saying anything of actual importance. The film does this juggling act of focusing on the showdown with the cops and the criminals with also focusing on other patients and the lead doctor's struggles with not being able to do her job as perfectly as she believes she can do it. The problem with all these ancillary characters is the fact that they don't really add much of anything to the main narrative. It's not like all these characters, together, contribute something of value to the A-team, as it were, they're just there because the film would have been way too short without them. Everyone is waiting for the climactic shootout, but I don't think the film is as taut as the premise may make it sound. You're just waiting for something to happen like you'd wait at a doctor's for 90 minutes before he is able to see you. There's no real tension to anything that is going on here. You know it's gonna come down to the climactic shootout, but you're not even really looking forward to it that much. Don't misunderstand me, the film is never bad, like at any point. But watching it feels more like a chore than anything else. And, this is something I've always believed, a chore to sit through is the worst thing a movie can be. You can take it or leave it and, if you do leave it, you wouldn't even be bothered by not having finished it. And that's just wrong. Plus it makes reviews more difficult to write since you don't really care much about anything, so you're not even motivated to write a review. With a shitty movie, you get to release all that stress and a negative review can, almost, be therapeutic. With a great movie, well, I mean you get to rave about an awesome movie and that's always fun. I just felt that if the film had anything to say while you're waiting for the shootout, then it wouldn't have been so bad. But there's no real point. The narrative just drags its feet. And then comes the shootout. You know how I said Johnnie To was the best at shootouts. Well, they can't all be winners. The idea is solid in theory. The entire scene plays out in slo-mo and you get to go all over the hospital, seeing the shootout from all possible angles with everyone in the hospital being caught in the crossfire. The problem I have with this is the fact that there's some moments where the actors themselves seem to be purposely walking in slo-mo and it's not an effect added in post-production. It looks so fucking bad and cheesy, because, and I only really noticed it twice, the actors do these really over-the-top and exaggerated slo-mo walk and it's just completely amateurish. The editing of the shootout also isn't perfect, but the placement of everybody and the actual shooting itself was, easily, the highlight of the film. It's just sad that one of the best people at pulling this type of scene off just had, from what I've seen, his first misfire. Good idea in theory, execution left a lot to be desired though. By and large, the rest of the movie is a misfire as well. It feels too long at 88 minutes, it just doesn't have an interesting narrative to sustain itself for the entire running length and that is on full-display when you actually sit down to watch this. Johnnie To has done much, much better and the intriguing concept is, really, just that. They barely do anything with it other than give you a dull and uninteresting film to sit through for its first 70 minutes, which is when the shootout happens. The shootout itself has a good idea, but the execution is really corny and substandard compared to Johnnie To's best works. Everything after that point is just closing out a disappointing movie in a disappointing fashion. While I'd say that this was fine, at best, as a fan of Johnnie To, this is just a major disappointment. I can't really give it any sort of recommendation, honestly. I gotta give them props for trying to do something different, but the movie just misses the mark. Watch Drug War or Exiled if you can find them somewhere else, those are quality movies. I'm feeling that 2.5 stars is really a generous rating, given the fact that I found very few positives about this. But I'll stick with that rating, since I feel that two stars is way too low. Watch this at your own risk, but I did not enjoy in the slightest. See more Jul 4, 2017 Watching this movie is almost as much a waste of time as playing solitaire on your computer. There's a lot of brain surgery, for people who like to see skulls drilled open and spurts of blood. From the poster I gather that the name of the movie refers to the three main ostensible protagonists. I say ostensible, because none of the three is a rounded character of any interest to anyone. Avoid this movie unless you're doing a residency in neurosurgery, and, even then, you probably have enough cutting at exposed brains to keep you happy. See more Jul 3, 2017 Me gusto, la escena de balazos al final vale toda la película. Igual la historia se me hizo original See more Read all reviews

Three

My Rating

Read More Read Less WRITE A REVIEW EDIT REVIEW POST RATING